

Starter 1999 · #40 · Common · 1999
Slow to sell
3 sold in the last 30 days, about one every 10 days. Busier than 23% of Magic cards priced under $2.
Lowest on TCGplayer · Near Mint · Normal $0.09 + $1.49 shipping · 45 listedView Paid link
Flying
When this creature enters, look at target player's hand.
From MTGJSON
TCGComps estimate · Near Mint
$0.40
Low confidence · $0.34 to $0.46 · TCGplayer market $0.40. TCGplayer market price; only 2 TCGplayer recorded sales.
TCGplayer
eBay
No eBay sales of this condition recorded.
Ingenious Thief
Ingenious Thief
2 of 2 shown
As of November 20, 2026, Ingenious Thief #40 (Starter 1999) is worth about $0.40 ungraded in Near Mint condition, by the TCGComps estimate (typical range $0.34 to $0.46, low confidence). TCGplayer market price; only 2 TCGplayer recorded sales.
Ingenious Thief is card 40 in Starter 1999, a Common Magic: The Gathering card released July 1, 1999. Prices are TCGComps estimates from TCGplayer and eBay sales of this exact card, condition and grade, each eBay sale checked against the card. How TCGComps prices cards Have this card or others like it? Scan them free in your browser with the MTG card scanner.