City in a Bottle BGS 9.5 price

Arabian Nights · Magic: The Gathering

As of November 21, 2026, City in a Bottle (Arabian Nights) graded BGS 9.5 is worth about $1,150.00, by the TCGComps estimate (typical range $1,150.00 to $1,275.00, low confidence). Based on 5 eBay sales in the last 3 years. That is 2.6 times its ungraded price of $445.83.

Last updated , when its newest BGS 9.5 sale was recorded.

City in a Bottle by grade

GradePriceSales behind it
BGS 9.5$1,150.005
CGC 10$839.502
BGS 9$500.009
CGC 9$450.001
BGS 8.5$390.006
BGS 7.5$390.001
CGC 8.5$371.205
BGS 8$340.604
BGS 7$300.001
CGC 7.5$295.604
CGC 8$295.444
CGC 7$295.442
SGC 7$290.361
CGC 6.5$287.342
CGC 4.5$287.341
CGC 5.5$264.681
PSA 5$260.252
Ungraded, Near Mint$445.83

Prices are TCGComps estimates from recorded sales of this exact card in this exact grade, each eBay sale checked against the card. The BGS 9.5 price chart on City in a Bottle’s page. How TCGComps prices cards