Old Man of the Sea CGC 8.5 price

Arabian Nights · Magic: The Gathering

As of November 21, 2026, Old Man of the Sea (Arabian Nights) graded CGC 8.5 is worth about $232.50, by the TCGComps estimate (typical range $184.60 to $265.00, low confidence). Based on 3 eBay sales in the last 3 years. Ungraded, it is worth about $231.25.

Last updated , when its newest CGC 8.5 sale was recorded.

Old Man of the Sea by grade

GradePriceSales behind it
BGS 9.5$909.003
CGC 10$550.001
CGC 9.5$414.504
CGC 9$371.663
BGS 9$330.003
BGS 8.5$275.005
BGS 8$275.004
BGS 7.5$275.001
PSA 8$263.954
PSA 7$263.951
CGC 3.5$256.252
CGC 8$246.854
CGC 8.5$232.503
CGC 7.5$232.501
CGC 6$232.501
CGC 5$205.001
SGC 7$187.501
Ungraded, Near Mint$231.25

Prices are TCGComps estimates from recorded sales of this exact card in this exact grade, each eBay sale checked against the card. The CGC 8.5 price chart on Old Man of the Sea’s page. How TCGComps prices cards