Tropical Island BGS 9.5 price

Unlimited Edition · Magic: The Gathering

As of November 20, 2026, Tropical Island (Unlimited Edition) graded BGS 9.5 is worth about $1,800.00, by the TCGComps estimate (typical range $1,400.00 to $2,250.00, low confidence). Based on 3 eBay sales in the last 180 days. That is 1.7 times its ungraded price of $1,035.00.

Last updated , when its newest BGS 9.5 sale was recorded.

Tropical Island by grade

GradePriceSales behind it
CGC 9.5$2,199.991
BGS 9.5$1,800.003
PSA 8$1,225.002
BGS 9$921.001
BGS 8$860.003
BGS 8.5$799.003
PSA 5$711.001
PSA 7$700.003
BGS 7.5$662.002
BGS 6$653.502
BGS 6.5$647.782
BGS 5$582.272
PSA 4$481.201
BGS 2.5$449.001
Ungraded, Near Mint$1,035.00

Prices are TCGComps estimates from recorded sales of this exact card in this exact grade, each eBay sale checked against the card. The BGS 9.5 price chart on Tropical Island’s page. How TCGComps prices cards