Toothy, Imaginary Friend

The List Reprints · #12 · Rare · Magic: The Gathering

What is Toothy, Imaginary Friend #12 worth?

As of November 21, 2026, Toothy, Imaginary Friend #12 (The List Reprints) is worth about $4.25 ungraded in Near Mint condition, by the TCGComps estimate (typical range $3.98 to $5.22, high confidence). Based on 45 TCGplayer sales in the last 30 days. TCGplayer's newest 45 sales ran 51% below the 6 before them, so only they count. TCGplayer's market price for the same copy is $4.82.

Last updated , when its newest sale was recorded.

Ungraded, by condition

Near Mint
$4.2545 sales in 30 days
Lightly Played
$3.611 sale

Toothy, Imaginary Friend is card 12 in The List Reprints, a Rare Magic: The Gathering card released October 3, 2008. Prices are TCGComps estimates from TCGplayer and eBay sales of this exact card, condition and grade, each eBay sale checked against the card. How TCGComps prices cards Have this card or others like it? Scan them free in your browser with the MTG card scanner.

Toothy, Imaginary Friend #12, The List Reprints (Magic: The Gathering)

Recent sales of Toothy, Imaginary Friend #12

SoldWhereCopyPrice
TCGplayerNear Mint$4.00
TCGplayerNear Mint$5.80
TCGplayerNear Mint$5.80
TCGplayerNear Mint$5.79
TCGplayerNear Mint$4.75

About the card

Partner with Pir, Imaginative Rascal (When this creature enters, target player may put Pir into their hand from their library, then shuffle.)

Whenever you draw a card, put a +1/+1 counter on Toothy.

When Toothy leaves the battlefield, draw a card for each +1/+1 counter on it.

Type
Legendary Creature — Illusion
Power
1
Colors
U
Keywords
Partner with, Partner
Mana Cost
{3}{U}
Mana Value
4
Toughness
1

Card data: MTGJSON.

Other printings