

Fourth Edition · Rare · 1995
TCGComps estimate · Near Mint
$2.05
Low confidence · $2.05 to $2.06 · TCGplayer market $2.06. Based on 7 TCGplayer sales in the last 180 days.
TCGplayer
eBay
No eBay sales of this condition recorded.
Steady
12 sold in the last 30 days, about one every 3 days. Busier than 41% of Magic cards priced $2–10.
Nightmare
Nightmare
Nightmare
Nightmare
Nightmare
5 of 7 shown
Sign in to see all salesFlying (This creature can't be blocked except by creatures with flying or reach.)
Nightmare's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Swamps you control.
From MTGJSON

Nightmare (Retro Frame)
30th Anniversary Edition · #412
—
As of November 20, 2026, Nightmare (Fourth Edition) is worth about $2.05 ungraded in Near Mint condition, by the TCGComps estimate (typical range $2.05 to $2.06, low confidence). Based on 7 TCGplayer sales in the last 180 days. TCGplayer's market price for the same copy is $2.06.
Nightmare is from Fourth Edition, a Rare Magic: The Gathering card released April 1, 1995. Prices are TCGComps estimates from TCGplayer and eBay sales of this exact card, condition and grade, each eBay sale checked against the card. How TCGComps prices cards Have this card or others like it? Scan them free in your browser with the MTG card scanner.