Challenge from the Darkness price list

As of November 20, 2026, all 99 cards in Challenge from the Darkness have a price on TCGComps: 4 are worth $100 or more, 19 are worth $20 or more, and one copy of each adds up to $1,895.71. The most valuable card is Sabrina's Gengar at $510.00, Near Mint.

Challenge from the Darkness cards by price band

PriceCardsTogether
$100 to $999.994$967.36
$20 to $99.9915$688.90
$5 to $19.9912$111.49
$1 to $4.9947$111.50
Under $121$16.46

Challenge from the Darkness cards by value

RankCardNumberPrice
1Sabrina's Gengar$510.00Near Mint
2Blaine's Charizard$230.00Near Mint
3Koga's Ninja Trick$125.22Near Mint
4Rocket's Mewtwo$102.14Near Mint
5Erika's Venusaur$79.99Near Mint
6Imakuni?'s Doduo$79.99Near Mint
7Blaine's Arcanine$67.21Near Mint
8Giovanni's Gyarados$66.85Near Mint
9Blaine's Moltres$58.85Near Mint
10_____'s Chansey$51.97Near Mint
11Rocket's Snorlax$38.05
12Rocket's Zapdos$37.87
13Sabrina's Gaze$35.07
14Sabrina's Alakazam$34.30
15Lt. Surge's Raichu$29.40
16Koga's Ditto$28.93
17Giovanni's Nidoking$28.36
18Giovanni's Persian$27.41
19Giovanni's Machamp$24.65
20Sabrina's Jynx$19.83
21Koga's Beedrill$18.10
22Sabrina's Haunter$10.82
23Giovanni$9.65
24Sabrina's Psyduck$7.75
25Erika's Ivysaur$7.39
26Giovanni's Nidoqueen$7.15
27Blaine's Ninetales$6.98
28Sabrina's Gastly$6.80
29Sabrina's Psychic Control$6.63
30Sabrina$5.26
31Blaine's Charmeleon$5.13
32Giovanni's Last Resort$4.69
33Sabrina's Venomoth$4.66
34Misty's Poliwrath$4.58
35Sabrina's Golduck$4.16
36Koga's Koffing (U)$4.03
37Rocket's Secret Experiment$3.83
38Viridian City Gym$3.68
39Sabrina's Kadabra$3.44
40Giovanni's Meowth (U)$3.39
41Giovanni's Pinsir$3.33
42Koga's Arbok$3.30
43Blaine's Rapidash$3.23
44Blaine$3.10
45Sabrina's Slowbro$2.97
46Blaine's Charmander$2.96
47Brock's Dugtrio$2.93
48Koga$2.60
49Koga's Muk$2.55
50Giovanni's Magikarp$2.53
51Giovanni's Machoke$2.51
52Saffron City Gym$2.40
53Koga's Pidgeotto$2.36
54Sabrina's ESP$2.30
55Minion of Team Rocket$2.18
56Koga's Weezing$2.10
57Tickling Machine$1.97
58Giovanni's Nidorino$1.95
59Blaine's Kangaskhan$1.94
60Sabrina's Slowpoke$1.92
61Sabrina's Hypno$1.71
62Blaine's Dodrio$1.67Moderately Played
63Blaine's Magmar$1.60
64Koga's Kakuna$1.49
65Rocket's Minefield Gym$1.48
66Giovanni's Meowth (C)$1.46
67Koga's Golbat$1.40
68Blaine's Vulpix$1.38
69Blaine's Growlithe$1.33
70Blaine's Quiz 3$1.31
71Cinnabar City Gym$1.29
72Koga's Pidgey (U)$1.25
73Sabrina's Abra$1.24
74Sabrina's Porygon$1.10
75Fuchsia City Gym$1.08
76Sabrina's Drowzee$1.07
77Sabrina's Mr. Mime$1.03
78Blaine's Last Resort$1.02
79Koga's Koffing (C)$0.99
80Koga's Tangela$0.99
81Blaine's Ponyta$0.94
82Blaine's Tauros$0.93
83Koga's Grimer$0.93
84Giovanni's Nidorina$0.89
85Koga's Ekans$0.89
86Sabrina's Venonat$0.87
87Giovanni's Machop$0.82
88Trash Exchange$0.79
89Warp Point$0.79
90Blaine's Doduo$0.78
91Giovanni's Nidoran F$0.76
92Koga's Weedle$0.74
93Giovanni's Nidoran M$0.71
94Koga's Pidgey (C)$0.68
95Blaine's Rhyhorn$0.67
96Koga's Zubat$0.66
97Transparent Walls$0.57
98Blaine's Mankey$0.56
99Blaine's Gamble$0.50

Each price is the one its tile shows across the site: the TCGComps estimate from TCGplayer and eBay sales where it has them, otherwise TCGplayer's market price for a Near Mint copy. A condition or grade under a price names the copy the estimate is for. How TCGComps prices cards